Do I have a treat for you! I’m sharing one of my signature, tried-and-true dishes. This is the dinner I bring to my friends after they’ve just had a baby. And it’s our Christmas Eve tradition. Ladies and gentlemen, I present you … Penne Pasta with Havarti and Kalamata Olives.

The recipe was given to me by a friend more than 10 years ago. I think it was from an online recipe site, but I’ve adapted it over the years to the recipe below. This is a hearty vegetarian dish, and can be made gluten-free by substituting the pasta for “penne” rice noodles if you wish. (I did that for a friend and it tasted just as good as the original.)

One of my favorite memories of eating this pasta was in a September 2007 massive heat wave. I was 8-months pregnant with Sophie and the only air-conditioned room in the house was our bedroom. Bryan, the dogs and I literally spent the entire weekend in that room, even eating our meals in there. This leftover pasta was one of the things we ate in our “bedroom refrigerator.”

Let me warn you this dish is time consuming to make. It’s super easy and is so worth the wait. But don’t attempt this when you get home at 8 p.m. and are starving. I like to make it Sunday nights and we enjoy the leftovers through the week.

Penne Pasta with Havarti and Kalamata Olives

4 Tbsp. olive oil

1 yellow onion, chopped

2 tsp. minced garlic

5 14 oz. cans of chopped tomatoes, drained

1 tsp. dried basil

1 tsp. crushed red pepper flakes

1 ½ cups chicken broth

1 pound penne pasta

2 cups packed grated Havarti cheese

¾ cup roughly chopped Kalamata olives

½ cup shredded Parmesan cheese

Salt and pepper to taste

Heat the olive oil in a large Dutch oven pot over medium-high heat. Add the chopped onion and garlic. Saute until translucent. Mix in tomatoes, dried basil, red pepper flakes, chicken broth, and salt and pepper. Bring mixture to a boil. Cover and reduce heat. Simmer until the mixture becomes chunky and is thickened. This typically takes one hour. This is the most time-consuming part of the dish.

When the tomato sauce is nearly complete, cook the penne pasta until al dente. This is really important: It MUST be al dente; even under-cooked. It will cook more when it’s mixed with the sauce and baked. Believe me – there’s nothing worse than eating pasta that’s over-cooked.

Meanwhile, preheat the oven to 375-degrees and spray a 9” x 13” baking dish. Chop the Kalamata olives and shred the cheese. Mix the drained pasta into the sauce (off the heat). Add the olives and cheese to the mixture and stir.

Dump the mixture into the baking dish. Top with shredded Parmesan cheese. Here’s another tip: I highly encourage you to use shredded Parmesan cheese, rather than grated. It forms a delicious crust on top that you’ll fight with your dinner guests on who will eat it. If you don’t have shredded, that’s okay. It turns out perfectly fine with grated Parmesan. But I encourage you to try the shredded at least once with this dish.

Bake until pasta is heated through, about 30 minutes. Remove from oven and let sit about 10 minutes before serving.

33 Responses

  1. That looks heavenly! You had me at the olives in the title, but all together it looks great. I definitely am doing post-baby visits and meal drop-offs very often these days! Thanks for sharing.

  2. This looks delicious and what great comfort food for a new mother. Amazing how I still remember the food some friends brought to help us get through those first few bewilderingly beautiful days. I often make a spinach tortellini dish (actually cheese tortellini in a deliciously gooey sauce of tomato, spinach, onion, cream cheese, etc.). Something about gooey pasta! yummmm.

  3. Yum! Sounds like I have another dish to add to our freezer stash for when the baby comes — and LOVE Bryan’s beer pairing suggestion. I can’t wait to be able to enjoy a cold one soon!

  4. Yum, yum, yum –Olives, cheese — yum! I’m going to make this soon, will let you know how it turns out!


  5. Definitely making this within the week!! Looks delicious & haven’t cooked with havarti before so can’t wait!

  6. Mmmmmm, mmmmm! This sounds and looks absolutely DE-licisous! May need the half the recipe. Can’t really imagine dad eating Kalamata olives. Does Sophie like the olives?Maybe I’ll a half and half dish, eah? Or take the olives out when I put dads’ in a bowl. Thanx for sharing 🙂

  7. I love pasta so much, I think I should’ve been Italian. I also loved the image of you and your husband eating this dish in your “bedroom refrigerator.”

    Isn’t it amazing how tastes or smells can take us back to a certain time? It’s like a pocket of memory.

    Thanks for sharing; I want to try this recipe out!

  8. Hi Leah, the card catalog belongs to my mom actually. We found it on craigslist this week and bought it for her. She plans to put it in the “grandchildren’s room” downstairs and use it to house legos, tinkertoys, baby socks, crayons, etc., etc. 🙂 Kelly

  9. Made this tonight and it was AMAZING! (but relooking at Leah’s photo, I will put much more parm cheese on next time, mine didn’t have enough of that wonderful parmesan crust on top!)

  10. I make a dish very much like this with mozarella — I’ll try Havarti next time. Yum!

    I second your endorsement of shredded Parmesan; I’ve gotten so I don’t even bother with the grated stuff. Isn’t it amazing how different it tastes? It’s the same stuff, after all, right?

  11. Hey Leah, Tried this dish last night and it was a huge success! fun to make, a joy to eat. leftovers for the week. THANK YOU!

  12. My mom shared this recipe with me several years ago. It is still a staple in our home. I add shrimp for protein and everybody loves it

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *